FR 2025-07347

The document from the Federal Register provides important information about the suspension and potential debarment of Mr. Peretz Klein from the Schools and Libraries Universal Service Support Mechanism, often known as the E-Rate Program, along with other related mechanisms. This notice comes from the Enforcement Bureau of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and is crucial for individuals or entities engaged with these programs.

General Summary

The document notifies the public that Mr. Peretz Klein has been suspended from participating in the E-Rate Program, which aims to make telecommunications and information services more affordable for schools and libraries. Furthermore, the FCC is initiating procedures that could lead to his permanent disbarment from this government program. Stakeholders, such as those who have or are considering contracts with Mr. Klein related to these services, are provided an opportunity to respond. They can file an opposition, supported by documentation, within 30 days from when they receive the suspension letter or by May 29, 2025, whichever comes first. The FCC has committed to addressing any oppositions within a 90-day period.

Significant Issues and Concerns

Several issues arise from the notice:

1. Lack of Specificity on Reasons for Suspension:

2. The document does not explain why Mr. Klein was suspended or the reasons behind the potential debarment proceedings. This omission limits transparency and leaves stakeholders without a full understanding of the situation.

3. Variability in Response Deadlines:

4. The timing for opposition requests could vary depending on when individuals receive the suspension notice. This can create inconsistencies and potential unfairness in how much time different parties have to respond, given that not everyone may receive the notification simultaneously.

5. Access to Information:

6. The document references a suspension letter critical to understanding the full context but does not include its contents. Stakeholders must access another document online to obtain complete information, which may present challenges for those with limited internet access or digital literacy.

7. Limited Contact Options:

8. The contact information is limited to email and telephone, which might not be accessible to everyone involved or affected, adding a barrier for those incapable of utilizing these communication methods.

Impact on the Public and Stakeholders

The document potentially impacts various groups both broadly and specifically:

• General Public:

• There is minimal immediate impact on the general public at large; however, the actions taken ensure continued integrity and trust in the use of public funds within the E-Rate Program. These programs indirectly benefit communities nationwide by supporting educational institutions.

• Stakeholders within the E-Rate Program:

• For those directly involved—particularly schools, libraries, and service providers—this situation may affect their ongoing and future contractual agreements and funding. If Mr. Klein is a signing party in any agreements, those stakeholders may need to reassess their relationships and contracts in compliance with FCC regulations.

• Mr. Peretz Klein and His Associates:

• For Mr. Klein and potentially contracted or partnering businesses, the suspension and the potential for debarment present significant operational challenges. They face immediate setbacks from the suspension and risk loss of eligibility for future participation based on the outcome of debarment proceedings.

Conclusion

The notice serves as a procedural step within the FCC's enforcement agenda, reflecting its commitment to oversight and accountability within federal programs. While the document addresses important regulatory actions, to optimize clarity and fairness, it could benefit from greater detail regarding the reasons for Mr. Klein's suspension and additional provisions for those affected by these actions.