Overview
Title
National Center for Complementary & Integrative Health; Notice of Closed Meeting
Agencies
ELI5 AI
The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health is having a secret virtual meeting on March 12, 2021, to talk about special ideas for music and health research. They want to keep things private to protect important secrets and personal information, and Martina Schmidt is the person to contact if you have any questions.
Summary AI
The National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health announced a closed meeting set for March 12, 2021. This meeting, held virtually due to confidentiality, is to review and evaluate grant applications, focusing on research related to music and health. Sensitive information about trade secrets and personal details will be discussed, ensuring privacy under the U.S. Code. For inquiries, Martina Schmidt, the Chief Office of Scientific Review, is the contact person.
Keywords AI
Sources
AnalysisAI
The document is a formal notice from the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health (NCCIH) about an upcoming meeting scheduled for March 12, 2021. This meeting, which will be conducted virtually, is designed to review and evaluate grant applications related to research on music and health. The rationale for the meeting being closed to the public is to protect sensitive information, including confidential trade secrets, commercial property such as potential patents, and personal information that may concern individuals involved in the grant applications.
General Summary
The announcement details an administrative process where experts meet to assess grant proposals for a program that seeks to explore the intersections of music and health. The document specifies the date and time of the meeting and provides contact information for Martina Schmidt, the chief of the Office of Scientific Review at NCCIH, for any inquiries.
Significant Issues
One pertinent issue is the justification for closing the meeting to the public, which is rooted in the need to protect confidential information. While the document justifies its decision by citing legal frameworks within the U.S. Code, it might leave the reader seeking a more in-depth explanation. The statements about confidentiality regarding "trade secrets or commercial property" and "personal privacy" might appear vague, potentially necessitating further examples to clarify the types of information protected.
Another concern is the absence of information on how stakeholders or interested members of the public may still engage with the outcomes of the meeting. Given the virtual nature of the session, additional details about ensuring confidentiality during the online meeting would also be beneficial.
Public Impact
For the general public, this document underscores the ongoing governmental processes to support innovative health research. The emphasis on music and health reflects a recognition of the potential therapeutic benefits of music, which could lead to novel health interventions and benefits for society.
Stakeholder Impact
For stakeholders, notably researchers and entities submitting grant applications, this meeting is a critical avenue toward receiving funding and acknowledgment for their work. However, their lack of access to information about the deliberations could pose a challenge, as they might not understand why certain applications succeed while others do not. Additionally, without a public version of meeting minutes or outcomes, applicants and the public alike might find it difficult to assess the fairness and transparency of the grant review process.
In conclusion, while the meeting is a vital step in supporting research endeavors, clarity and transparency about the process, especially regarding confidentiality and engagement, may enhance trust and understanding among all parties involved.
Issues
• The document states that the meeting will be closed to the public due to confidentiality concerns, but it does not provide detailed justification or criteria for this decision.
• The language regarding confidentiality, specifically concerning 'trade secrets or commercial property' and 'personal privacy', may be seen as vague as it does not detail specific examples of what type of information would be protected.
• The meeting's location is specified as a virtual meeting, but there is no information on how stakeholders or interested members of the public might participate or receive information about the meeting results or decisions.
• The document does not mention if there are any measures or protocols in place to ensure that confidentiality is maintained during the virtual meeting.
• There is no information about whether there will be any public version of the meeting minutes or outcomes released after the meeting.